Into the Water by Paula Hawkins

From the author of The Girl on the Train, Paula Hawkins, comes the new novel Into the Water. While The Girl on the Train was a psychological thriller, Into the Water is more a mystery novel, in my opinion. I loved Hawkins’ debut novel and were really looking forward to her latest.

The story is narrated from the point of view of various characters.  It plays off in a small town called Beckford and centers on the mystery of ‘The Drowning Pool’, labelled that way as many women have died in the river. It starts off with Jules being informed of her sister Nel’s death. Nel Abbott who investigated the deaths of all the ‘troublesome’ women that died in the drowning pool, convinced that there is more to the story.

Nel’s death, weeks after a teenage girl’s drowning, is believed to be suicide, however her 15 year old daughter, Lena does not seem to think so (who coincidently is also the best friend of the deceased girl, Katie).  Being forced to return to her hometown because of her sister’s death, Jules finds herself being haunted by her past. She had a strained relationship with Nel because of events that happened in their teenage years and now she is back in town having to take care of her niece, who she met for the first time upon her return.

I found Into the Water to be a satisfying thriller with more than enough drama to keep the reader invested in the story. There is a slow build of suspense in the beginning, but it picks up about a quarter of the way through. There’s abuse, deception, suicide, rape, murder and unreliable characters that carries with them a myriad of secrets.

In addition, there’s more darkness to the novel with claims of witchcraft, but the story moves into the eerie territory in the second half of the novel. At first I thought I was disappointed that the deaths of the women over the centuries had nothing to do with witches, but then that would be a little too farfetched, wouldn’t it?

The twists in the story were both expected and unexpected in equal measure, with the last twist to be the most surprising of all (to me, at least). I can’t say more about the plot without revealing too much and from all the unlikable characters in the novel, I liked Lena the most. She may have been a troublesome teen with a bad attitude in the beginning, but I think out of all she grew the most. Jules on the other hand has shown some growth too, but she learned an import lesson: it’s better to tell someone what is troubling you than keeping quiet and having to live with regret.

Disclaimer: I received this book from Penguin Random House for review consideration.

Image source: from my instagram page. Please give me a follow, my account is still fairly new.

  • Nishita

    I disliked Jules so much, didn’t care for Lena or Nel either. I did feel for that Inspector though.

  • Readers seem to be of two minds about this book, but I am glad that it worked well for you.

    • I have noticed that, yes. I do think that The Girl on the Train was better, though.

  • I didn’t read The Girl on the Train, but if this is more of a mystery, that very much appeals to me. I’m not sure how I will like so many unlikable characters, but I might pick this one up! Great review!

    • Thank you Charlene. The Girl on the Train was better, but I think that because I thought this to be more of a mystery, I didn’t compare it to the debut novel of the author. Are you not partial to psychological thrillers?

      • Oh ok, I will have to think about that then. I do prefer a good old fashioned mystery to psychological thrillers, but I do read both!

  • Got this but have yet to get to it: seems to have garnered mixed reviews, which is why I’m hesitant about reading it – although I will read it at some point. Great review; very informative compared to some. Thank you!

  • I’ve been wondering about this one – I noticed the audiobook on TuneIn Radio today. Glad to read your thoughts on it, I’m going to put it on my list!

    • Hope you will enjoy it, Monika. I know it received some mixed reviews in the book community.

  • literaryfeline

    I haven’t been hearing very good things about this one, and so it was nice to come across your review. This is one I want to try. I enjoyed The Girls on the Train and the synopsis for this one interests me. I don’t mind unlikable characters, depending in the type of book. Thank you for your great review, Melinda!

    • Thank you. I will say that it’s not as good as The Girl on the Train though, so I understand the mixed reviews. As long as you don’t go into the read with TGOTT expectations, it should be a nice read, I think…

  • Ciska van der Lans

    Not sure if the witch part would be really for me. This book is everywhere and I am curious. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

    • Don’t worry, that never materialized. Just one of the characters that were thought to be a witch and of course a rumor that one of the deaths was due to witchcraft, which it was not 🙂

      You should be good.

  • This sounds like a really interesting mystery. I’ve seen it around a bit and am looking for a thriller to pick up this summer. I like the sound of this one exploring eerie territory too. Lovely review!

    • Thanks, Alicia. If you’re looking for a thriller, you should definitely give The Girl on the Train a read too.

  • Isi

    I didn’t know there was another book by Paula Hawkins! I didn’t love The girl on the train, but I didn’t dislike it either, so I might try this new mystery novel.

    • I liked TGOTT more than this one, but who knows, you might enjoy this one more! Give it a try 🙂